MovilleInishowen.com.
*
 
Back to home page 
     

 

 

 


   

 

John Toland (1670-1721)
Researched and compiled by Gerry McElroy

John Toland philosopher, was born 30th November 1670 in the parish of Clonmany. While his family origins remain obscure, it appears that he was baptised into the Catholic Church as Johannes Eugenius, or Sean Owens. Some of his protagonists later in life claimed that he was the illegitimate child of a local priest but this has never been established.

He appears to have worked as a shepherd until the age of fourteen, and it is around this time, that he converted to Protestantism. It remains unknown as to whether this conversion was based on religious believe or a desire for self improvement, but in any case, he was enrolled at a school in Redcastle where he received formal education, and was seen by his sponsors as a potential missionary to other Irish Language speakers.

He left Ireland sometime in his teens, and at the age of eighteen was named an 'Alumnus Academicus', a full scholarship student of theology at the College (later University of Glasgow. In 1688 or 1689 he moved to Edinburgh and was awarded a MA by the University of Edinburgh in late 1689. He had already supported Presbyterian over Anglican claims in church-state relations in Scotland, and in the early 1690s, moved to London to work as a theological tutor. He appears to have written his first book in this period. The Sage of the Times, which appeared in both English and French, but no trace of the book exists.

From this time, certain traits would shape the rest of his life: the need for aristocratic patrons to fund his prolific writing which numbered nearly two hundred items in theology and politics; his apparent desire to please his patrons which frequently created contradictions and apparent compromises in much of his work, causing great controversy; a remarkable linguistic capacity (he could apparently use ten languages which helped him to work in a variety of countries and publish in different languages).

In 1692 he attended the universities of Utrecht and Leiden, and while fulsome in his praise of Dutch freedom, returned to England the following year. He then renounced a clerical career, and lived in Oxford, working for a time as a compiler of an Irish dictionary. It was during this period he became friendly with John Locke, one of England's most famous philosophers, who later denied any friendship after they had fallen out.

He soon found himself at the centre of one of the great controversies of his life because of his book, Christianity Not Mysterious (1695). This work scandalised public opinion as it argued that human reason could explain biblical mysteries. The work was condemned by the Commons and Bishops in England, and when he returned to Ireland to escape the controversy, he discovered establishment opinion back home was even more hostile; the Irish House of Commons condemned it as heretical in 1697, claiming that it subverted belief in the divinity of Christ, ordered that the text he burned and its author arrested. Fearing for his life, Toland returned to England, only to find that the controversy would not go away. As a result, he went back to Holland in 1699 for a while, later found a patron for many years in Robert Harley, one-time Chancellor of the Exchequer, and spent much of 1702 in Brunswick and Berlin, engaging in public debate with the famous German philosopher, Leibniz.

Whether through belief or opportunism, he tried to retrieve his shattered reputation in England by later describing himself as an Anglican, but throughout his wanderings and apparently changing beliefs, continued to publish an enormous variety of works. As well as that, he continued to rub shoulders with some of the most influential figures of his day including William Penn, the founder of the Society of Friends (Quakers), and author, Daniel Defoe.

Experiencing bad health, virtual bankruptcy as a result of investment losses in the South Sea Bubble, and a serious drink problem, he published Pantheisticon in 1720. Frightened of religious persecution, he originally published the work in Latin so it would be accessible to a limited readership but it was to become his most famous work. His fear was well founded because Toland's conception of pantheism was heretical, given that he saw the material universe as the only divine being.

Ireland's most famous philosopher, Toland possessed a remarkable intellect and command of languages, not least given his apparent lack of childhood education. He is best remembered for coining the term 'pantheism', being the first materialist and scientific pantheist of modern times, and the first to conceive of a network of societies observing the pantheist religion.

He never married. In 1721, only a year after the publication of Pantheisticon, he died in poverty and obscurity in his lodgings at Putney, south-west London, and is buried in a local graveyard.

Click here to read history of pantheism

Back

Click here to visit the IRDL website.
Supported by the NE Inishowen Company.